Predictive Dialers and Call Progress Detection

May, 2010

Watch out for predictive dialer vendors claiming over 90% (sometimes over 95%) detection rates for answering machines. This is not real life, and here's why.

Predictive dialers aren’t necessarily just about raw dialing performance. In the eyes of many users, they are also about the ability of the dialer to do ‘call progress detection’ to screen out as many non-live calls as possible. In the US especially, this usually becomes a debate about how effective is answer machine detection (AMD). The truth is that provided the algorithms are well-tuned (which isn’t that difficult), there isn’t a lot of difference between manufacturers.

Watch out for the marketing handouts that claim over 90% (sometimes over 95%) detection rates for answering machines. One not insubstantial US vendor even claims, publicly, 100% accuracy. Watch out for 105% next!

Here is a typical example of the kind of artificial test that produces such high claims. The dialer gets one of two responses:

  1. Live answer of a single “Hello” followed by silence, or
  2. Answering machine greeting of continuous speech such as “Thank you for calling. We are not in at the moment. Please leave a message.”

Any answering machine detection algorithm not being 100% accurate under such conditions deserves a good telling off!

But this is not real life. For example, what about the person who answers the phone, saying “Hello, John Smith here”, and then when he doesn’t get an immediate response starts saying “Hello…Hello…”?

In the UK, the telecoms regulator Ofcom has realised that because answering machines aren’t that accurate, they sometimes hang up on live people in the belief that they are answering machines. Such calls are deemed false positives and they count towards the strict limit of 3% allowed for abandoned calls under Ofcom rules. For some time now there has been a rather silly debate in the UK as to whether the use of answering machine detection and thus false positives on the one hand and predictive dialing on the other are compatible. They simply aren’t and one day Ofcom may have the courage to say so, stop the debate and allow us all to focus on more productive things.

But give Ofcom its due. At least they know about false positives. No other regulator appears to understand the issue and in countries such as the US, call centers are free to deploy answering machine detection without any fear of censure, through lack of accuracy.

So does unfettered use of answer machine detection make sense, when regulations don’t get in the way? Ask yourself this – and it applies to the UK too. Why would you want to take all live calls and hold them all up for a number of seconds trying to figure out if they are a machine or not? How do you feel as a consumer when this happens to you? Many people would either hangup or just get annoyed. Imagine what that does to the quality of the call if a consumer stays on the line? And that’s why savvy call centers don’t go there because the loss in agent talk time per hour is more than compensated for by the improvement in call quality that an immediate connect brings. And there is another benefit: when the agent encounters an answering machine he can leave what is clearly a personalised message rather than a canned one.

The good thing about these ideas, even for the most dyed in the wool advocates of answering machine detection, is that you can test for the impact, by turning detection on and then off, and measuring the differential impact on bottom line performance over time.

We apologise for the unusually long blog this month, but these are serious matters. Sure we are opinionated (but based on very extensive experience in many countries) and in search of brevity have perhaps cut some corners. If you want more, or to debate any of our conclusions, just let us know.

What We Offer

Sytel Limited develops and supplies Softdial Contact Center® (SCC), offering multimedia, multichannel, fully blended cloud contact center solutions, for quick and easy deployment by partners offering CCaaS or enterprise users. All Sytel cloud components are secure, resilient and scale seamlessly from 10 agents to 10,000+, whether local, mobile or remote.

  • Flexible Contact Center Platform

    Softdial Contact Center™ – tightly integrated modules, designed to deliver at scale

  • Blended Media Desktop

    Fully customisable, multi-channel, multi-session workspace

  • Work Anywhere

    Browser-based tools, no software installation required

  • Cloud Or On-Premise, Multi-Tenant

    Scalable, resilient, secure, proven

  • Customise, Localise, White Label

    Design all user interfaces to individual requirements

  • Integration Via APIs

    ‘Swap out’ components and integrate with 3rd party apps

  • World Class Development

    Continuous evolution pushing technical boundaries

Capabilities

Softdial Contact Center™ (SCC) is designed to be flexible, extensible and scalable, integrating with any legacy equipment, and meeting the most complex of requirements.

  • All Media Types

    Voice, chat, email, social, etc – fully integrated and blended

  • Agent Multi-Tasking

    Work with multiple live contact sessions of any media type

  • Dynamic Media Blending

    Automated, ‘best available’ decisions to blend and balance work load across all media types

  • Predictive Dialing

    Best-of-breed performance under compliance

  • Intelligent Routing

    Smart rules and ‘best-available’ decisions to drive great customer service

  • Agent Scripts

    Help agents achieve and maintain excellence

  • Voice and Screen Recording

    See and hear exactly how agents are interacting

  • Analytics and Data Feeds

    Measure and evaluate performance at every level

  • IVR, Bots & Conversational AI

    Design effective automated flows or integrate with 3rd party providers

  • Customer Journey Tracking

    Stored customer contact history, to aid routing and add context to conversations

Modules

A complete suite of tools, with unique flexibility to extend and swap out modules to deliver a tailored contact center solution for any environment

  • Softdial One™

    Highly flexible unified web UI for agents, supervisors and administrators

  • Softdial Scripter™

    Create complex process flow scripts for agents, IVR, chatbots and other applications

  • Sytel AI Dialer™

    Best-of-breed predictive dialing under any compliance rules

  • Softdial Pathfinder™

    Precise routing rules for ‘best available’ connection

  • Softdial Media Server™

    Core telephony functions to manage all inbound/ outbound SIP calls

  • Softdial Reporter™ 5

    Fully customisable performance stats, charts and reports, across all channels

  • Softdial Publisher™

    Comprehensive data output to build your own reports

  • Softdial Recording Monitor™

    Audio and screen recording of agent activity to ensure the highest standards

  • Softdial Campaign Manager™

    Comprehensive configuration and control for outbound campaigns

  • Softdial Repository™

    Central storage and configuration of common resources

  • Sytel Global Compliance™

    Flexible ‘no contact’ rules to protect contact center and consumer

Markets

Performance and efficiency for a wide range of business applications

  • Customer Service

    Connect quickly to well equipped agents

  • Sales & Telemarketing

    Maximise agent productivity with best-of-breed predictive dialing

  • Healthcare

    Secure, highly-configurable multichannel communications for excellence in patient care

  • Market Research

    Best-of-breed predictive dialing with CATI integration

  • Collections

    Automated inbound/ outbound blending integrated with any debt management app